Nobody who has run the same organization for eight years thinks they've stayed too long. I haven't met one.
I get why. You know where everything is buried. The board trusts you. Your team can finish your sentences. It all feels like stability, and stability used to be the whole point of leadership.
That assumption deserves a harder look. In March, Ivy Exec made the case that a leader's time in the seat is "rarely the best indicator of success." It argued that the real test is whether you're still creating value, and I agree. The research behind that argument is sharper than most leaders expect, though, and it points to a specific way long tenure goes wrong.
The data: there is a peak, and most leaders stay past it
Xueming Luo, Vamsi Kanuri and Michelle Andrews tracked CEOs at 365 U.S. companies from 2000 to 2010. Their findings, published in the Strategic Management Journal, showed that CEO impact on firm performance rises, peaks and then declines. On average the peak came at about 4.8 years. The average CEO in the sample stayed 7.6 years.
That's roughly three years past the point of best impact.
The mechanism matters more than the number. Luo explained that entrenched CEOs start leaning on their internal networks for information and become "less attuned to market conditions." The organization keeps looking healthy from the inside while it drifts away from the customer.
This isn't new thinking either. In 1991, Donald Hambrick and Gregory Fukutomi described the "seasons" of a CEO's tenure in the Academy of Management Review. A leader moves from responding to the mandate, through experimenting, to choosing an enduring theme, and then to convergence. The last season is dysfunction. The pattern that got you results in year four becomes the pattern you defend in year nine.
The market has already noticed
Boards are acting on this. Spencer Stuart's 2025 S&P 1500 CEO Transitions report counted 168 new CEOs in 2025, the most since 2010. Departing CEOs had served an average of 8.5 years, down from 9.2 in 2024 and 10.3 in 2021. Thirty-seven percent left within five years, and 84 percent of the new appointees were first-time CEOs.
The takeaway isn't that short tenures are good. It's that boards now treat tenure as something to justify rather than something to reward.
Tenure isn't the problem. The operating system is.
Here's where I part ways with the usual "when should you leave?" conversation. Treating leadership tenure as a countdown clock gets it wrong. Tenure is a stress test. It shows whether the way you lead can keep renewing itself or whether it only works when you're personally holding it together.
Stephen Covey had a name for this. He called it the P/PC Balance, meaning the balance between Production (the golden eggs) and Production Capability (the goose). Long-tenured leaders get very good at collecting eggs. The quiet risk is that they stop feeding the goose: new perspectives, outside information, leaders who can make decisions without them.
In the Breakfast Leadership Operating System, this failure has a name: the Coordination Ceiling. Over time every important decision, relationship and exception starts routing through one person. That feels like mastery. What it really means is that the organization can't move faster than you can.
A Leadership OS diagnostic for your tenure
Ivy Exec asked two good questions: are you still learning, and are you driving change or maintaining the status quo? I'd turn them into a diagnostic built on the four pillars of the Leadership OS.
1. Alignment: is the team aligned to the strategy, or to you?
Early on, those are the same thing. Later they split apart. If your people can predict your reaction better than they can explain the strategy, alignment has turned into deference.
2. Decision Clarity: which decisions still need you?
List the last ten meaningful decisions. Count how many waited on your calendar. If that number has grown with each year of your tenure, you're the ceiling.
3. Resilience: are you renewing, or running on reserves?
This is the one leaders won't say out loud. Burnout in long-tenured executives rarely shows up as collapse. It looks like stability: the same playbook, the same meetings, less curiosity. I learned this the hard way, and it's the reason I wrote Burnout Proof. A tired leader can look a lot like a steady one.
4. Sustainable Performance: would results hold if you left for 90 days?
If the honest answer is no, your tenure hasn't built an organization. It has built a dependency.
When staying longer is the right call
Staying isn't wrong. Ivy Exec is right that continuity earns its keep during turnarounds, major transformations and multi-year builds, where trust and consistency are the strategy. The research doesn't argue for shorter tenures. It argues for intentional ones.
Covey's second habit, Begin with the End in Mind, applies here. The leaders who stay well decide their exit criteria before they need them. For example:
Define what "done" looks like for your current mandate, in writing, and review it with your board every year.
Rebuild your outside inputs on purpose. Put customer conversations, peer advisory groups and reverse mentoring on the calendar, not just in your intentions.
Move decision rights down every year. If your decision load isn't shrinking, your succession plan is fiction.
Invest in culture that outlasts you. The strongest legacy is a team that no longer needs you in every room. I cover this in depth in Workplace Culture.
The real question
"How long have I been here?" is the wrong question. The better one is whether your leadership is still compounding or whether you're coasting on what you built years ago.
If you can't answer that with confidence, that's your answer, and it doesn't have to mean leaving. It may mean rebuilding how you lead from the operating system up.
Book a Leadership Operating System review at BreakfastLeadership.com/LeadershipOS. We'll map where your Coordination Ceiling sits and what it will take to make your next five years your most productive yet.
For more on leadership systems, burnout prevention and culture, visit the Breakfast Leadership blog.
Sources: