Look at your leave balances this week. If your managers are sitting on weeks of unused PTO heading into December, you are not looking at a generous benefit going to waste. You are looking at a reading from your operating system, and it is telling you that time away is not safe, not covered, or not modeled from the top.
Most companies treat unused PTO as an HR housekeeping issue. They send a reminder email in November, adjust the carryover rule, and move on. The pattern returns every year because the cause was never the policy. It is the way work is assigned, covered and judged when someone steps away.
This article is written for CEOs and senior leaders of mid-sized organizations. It covers what the research says about who leaves time on the table and why, why your managers are the group most likely to skip vacation, how workload and coverage gaps drive the pattern, where AI fits, and the specific rules a leadership team can set to make rest part of how the company runs rather than something people must earn.
What Unused PTO Tells a CEO About the System
The size of the problem is well documented. In a Pew Research Center survey of U.S. workers fielded in February 2023, 46% of workers who receive paid time off said they take less time off than their employer offers. That is close to half of the people a leadership team has explicitly given permission to rest.
Pew's breakdown is where the leadership signal appears. Salaried workers were more likely than hourly workers to take less time than offered, 52% versus 39%. Workers with a bachelor's degree or more were more likely to do so than those with less education, 51% versus 41%. Put simply, the people most likely to leave time unused are the ones whose work is least bounded by a shift and most dependent on judgment.
That matters because those are the roles that carry decisions, client relationships and institutional knowledge. When they do not step away, nobody else learns to step in.
The first move for a CEO is to stop reading this as an individual choice. Ask HR for a simple report: PTO taken as a share of PTO available, by department and by level, for the last twelve months. Do not use it to shame anyone. Use it to locate the parts of the organization where work cannot survive an absence. Those teams are your concentration risk, and the leave data finds them faster than any engagement survey will.
Why Managers Are the Group Most Likely to Skip Vacation
Pew found that managers were more likely than nonmanagers to say they take less time off than is available to them, 54% versus 42%. Your managers are not just the people who approve vacation requests. They are the group least likely to use their own.
This is not a discipline problem. It is a design problem. A manager who is the only person able to approve spend, answer a client escalation or unblock a direct report cannot leave without the work stalling. Every decision that routes through one person turns that person's vacation into an operational risk, so they quietly cancel it.
It also sets the norm for everyone below them. Employees take their cues from what their manager does, not what the handbook says. A team whose manager answers email from the airport learns that time off is technically allowed and practically discouraged.
There are three things to fix here. Write down which decisions each manager can hand to a named deputy while they are out, and make that deputy's authority real, including spend limits. Require every manager to schedule at least one full week away each year and put it on the leadership calendar early, the same way you schedule a board meeting. And ask your executive team to go first. If the CEO and the C-suite do not take visible, uninterrupted time off, no policy below them will hold.
Workload and Coverage Drive the Pattern
When Pew asked workers who do not take all their time off why, 49% said they would worry about falling behind at work, and 43% said they would feel badly about co-workers taking on additional work. Only about half, 52%, said they simply did not feel they needed more time off.
Read those numbers as an operations report. Worry about falling behind means work piles up during an absence instead of being redistributed. Guilt about colleagues means the coverage plan is "someone else absorbs it on top of their full job." Neither is a mindset issue that a wellness webinar will solve.
Gallup's research on burnout points at the same root. In its study of nearly 7,500 full-time employees, Gallup identified unmanageable workload and unreasonable time pressure among the five factors most correlated with burnout. Employees who said they often or always have enough time to do their work were 70% less likely to experience high burnout.
The fix is to plan coverage before the absence, not after it. For any role that carries client or decision load, require a written handoff that lists open items, who owns each one while the person is out, and what can wait. Then remove work rather than reassigning all of it. If a project would not survive one week without its lead, it was understaffed before anyone booked a flight.
The Cost of Unused PTO Shows Up as Burnout and Turnover
Unused leave is not a neutral saving. Gallup's burnout study found that employees who very often or always experience burnout are 63% more likely to take a sick day and 2.6 times as likely to be actively seeking a different job. The time people decline to take as planned leave tends to come back as unplanned absence, and in some cases as a resignation.
The same research shows how much the manager relationship matters. Employees who strongly agreed that they feel supported by their manager were about 70% less likely to experience burnout on a regular basis. Support in this context is concrete. It means a manager who protects time off, redistributes work fairly and does not send a follow-up on the second day of someone's vacation.
For a CEO, the connection to retention is direct. The employees most likely to skip time off are salaried, educated and often in management. Those are expensive people to replace, and they are the ones who carry the knowledge your succession plan depends on.
Treat a sustained pattern of unused PTO on a team as an early warning indicator, alongside overtime and attrition. When a department combines low leave usage with rising sick days or regretted exits, do not wait for the next engagement survey. Look at that team's workload and its manager's capacity now.
Where AI Fits: Coverage Support, Not a Reason to Stay Online
AI tools are changing the coverage problem in two directions, and leaders need to decide which one wins.
Used well, AI makes absence easier to cover. Meeting summaries, searchable project notes and drafted status updates can shorten a handoff from an afternoon to an hour, and they let a deputy pick up a thread without calling the person on the beach. That is a real reduction in the "falling behind" worry that Pew's respondents described, 49% of those who leave time unused.
Used carelessly, AI does the opposite. When the same tools that summarize the inbox are on a phone, the expectation quietly becomes that everyone can check in for five minutes a day. Productivity gains from AI get spent on more availability rather than more rest, and the burnout drivers Gallup identified, workload and time pressure, get worse rather than better.
This is a decision the leadership team should make deliberately rather than let drift. Set a clear rule: AI tools may prepare handoffs, summarize what happened during an absence and route routine requests to the named deputy. A person on leave is not expected to review AI outputs, approve AI drafted messages or respond to automated alerts. Anything that requires a human decision goes to the deputy, not to the person on vacation. Write that rule into your AI usage guidance and your leave policy at the same time, so neither undermines the other.
Conclusion: Make Time Off Part of the Operating System
Unused PTO is not a perk problem. It is a leadership system problem. The research is consistent: nearly half of workers with paid time off leave some of it unused, managers do so more than anyone, and the reasons people give are workload, coverage and guilt rather than a lack of interest in rest. Gallup's work shows where that leads, toward burnout, sick days and people looking for the exit.
The fix sits with the executive team. Pull the leave data by team and level and treat low usage as a risk indicator. Give every manager a deputy with real decision authority. Require written handoffs and remove work rather than piling it on colleagues. Set an explicit rule for how AI supports coverage without pulling people back online. And take your own time off where your team can see it.
If you want help building those rules into how your company actually runs, a Leadership OS review is the place to start. Book an intake call with Michael and bring your leave data with you.
One leader taking a real week off is a good habit. Every manager able to take one is a system.
Deputies, written handoffs and visible executive time off are the right practices. They are also fragile, because they depend on a busy leader remembering them in a crunch, and they erode the moment a quarter-end deadline turns a deputy back into a bottleneck and a vacation into a "quick check-in."
Leadership Operating System
When managers cannot leave without work stalling, the gap is in how decisions and coverage are designed, not in anyone's willpower. See how a Leadership OS review works.
AI Adoption Advisory
AI can shorten handoffs and cover routine requests during an absence, but only if your rollout rules say a person on leave is never expected to review its output. See how fractional AI adoption advisory works.
Book a call Either track starts the same way.
Michael D. Levitt is the founder of Breakfast Leadership Network and the author of Burnout Proof and Workplace Culture. More writing at the Breakfast Leadership blog.
Additional Resources
How to Help Your Employees Achieve Work Life Balance: https://www.breakfastleadership.com/blog/2021/7/8/how-to-help-your-employees-achieve-work-life-balance
Employee Retention: Calculating the True Costs of Burnout and Turnover: https://www.breakfastleadership.com/blog/employee-retention-calculating-the-true-costs-of-burnout-and-turnover
A Result of Burnout: 1 in 5 Employees Would Prefer Five Extra PTO Days Rather Than a 10% Raise: https://www.breakfastleadership.com/blog/2019/11/11/a-result-of-burnout-1-in-5-employees-would-prefer-five-extra-pto-days-rather-than-a-10-raise
Sources
Pew Research Center, "More than 4 in 10 U.S. workers don't take all their paid time off," August 10, 2023: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/08/10/more-than-4-in-10-u-s-workers-dont-take-all-their-paid-time-off/
Gallup, "Employee Burnout, Part 1: The 5 Main Causes," July 12, 2018: https://www.gallup.com/workplace/237059/employee-burnout-part-main-causes.aspx